Property Prediction



4       Synthia


Introduction

The Synthia module allows you to make rapid estimates of polymer properties using empirical and semi-empirical methods.
Synthia can predict a wide range of thermodynamic, mechanical, and transport properties for bulk amorphous homopolymers and statistical copolymers. The key advantage of Synthia is that it uses connectivity indices as opposed to group contributions in its correlations; this means that no database of group contributions is required, and properties may be predicted for any polymer comprised of any of the following nine elements: carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, oxygen, silicon, sulfur, fluorine, chlorine, or bromine. This methodology is based on research conducted by Dr. Jozef Bicerano (1993) of The Dow Chemical Company.

Sections in this chapter

Using Synthia

General methodology

Computing repeat unit length

Energy minimization of repeat units

Values of cohesive energy and solubility parameter used in correlations for other properties

Representation of amide groups

Performing polymer properties calculations

Theory

References


Using Synthia

This section contains a simple example to get you started with the Synthia module. Steps you must perform for the tutorial to work as designed are in boxes. Explanations are printed in italics. Command, popup, and pushbutton names are given in bold.

The specific example described in this section allows you to estimate the solubility parameter and the Young's modulus of an ethylene-propylene copolymer over a range of concentrations at room temperature. Note that the predictions of the Synthia module apply to an isotropic, atactic, amorphous polymer phase; the effects of ordering, tacticity, and crystallinity, in particular, are not taken into account. The results in this example thus apply to the amorphous regions of the copolymer.

This example is divided into sections:

A. Building the copolymer

B. Predicting properties

C. Studying a range of concentrations

A. Building the copolymer

1.   Starting Cerius2

Open a new UNIX shell and type:

>	cerius2 

2.   Accessing Synthia

From the Visualizer panel, go to the POLYMER Deck and choose the SYNTHIA card.

3.   Load the monomer subunits and build the copolymer

Select the Study/Copolymer item to bring up the Copolymer control panel.

In the box labeled Polymer enter co_eth_prop as a name for your new copolymer.

Click the arrow to the right of the first Monomer Name text field. Select polyolefin from the list of monomer types.

Click once again on the same arrow.

You now see a list of monomers under the category polyolefin.

Select PE from the list.

You have now loaded the ethylene monomer.

Now click the arrow to the right of the second Monomer Name text field. This time select polyolefin and then PP from the list.

You have now loaded the propylene monomer. Note that the concentrations of the two monomers are each equal to 0.5. This is because neither concentration has been marked as fixed; the program automatically divides unassigned concentrations equally among unfixed monomers.

4.   Load the copolymer into Synthia

Click the blue button labeled Add Copolymer to NEW Study.

This loads your copolymer into Synthia. Note that the two monomers are loaded in as models and that the propylene monomer is displayed in the model window.

5.   Display the study table

Select the Study/Show item on the SYNTHIA card.

This brings up a table displaying the name of your copolymer, the structures of each constituent monomer, their respective concentrations, and the default temperature and molecular weight for the study (298 K and 100000 respectively).

B. Predicting properties

1.   Open the menu of properties

Go to the SYNTHIA card and select the Properties/Select item.

This brings up the Select Properties panel. The panel should display the Thermophysical category by default.

2.   Choose the thermophysical properties

Scroll through the list of properties on the panel and select Solubility Parameter (van Krevelen).

3.   Choose the mechanical properties

Click the yellow popup labeled Thermophysical and select Mechanical.

This displays a list of mechanical properties.

Select Young's Modulus from the list.

4.   Predict the selected properties for the copolymer

Now go to the Study Table and click the PREDICT button.

The selected properties should be displayed in the table for the copolymer made up of ethylene and propylene in equal mole fractions. (Other mole fractions can be entered by checking the box marked Fixed (located to the right of the monomer name) for a monomer and then typing in a value into the box to its right.)

C. Studying a range of concentrations

1.   Initiate a concentration study

Select the Study/Concentration Range item on the
SYNTHIA card.

This brings up the Concentration Range panel. The name co_eth_prop should be displayed in the text field labeled Polymer.

Click the yellow Range popup currently displaying the value None.

You will see a list of allowed range monomers for co_eth_prop.

Set the popup to PE.

2.   Set the concentration step

Enter a Concentration Step of 0.2.

3.   Display the range in the study table

Check the box labeled Display Range in Table.

You should see six rows displayed in the table, one corresponding to each set of compositions in the range just defined. Note that both the Young's modulus and the solubility parameter increase monotonically with rising ethylene fraction.

4.   Plot the solubility parameter

Click the down arrow next to Over Range and select
Solubility Parameter.

Click the Plot button.

This graphically displays the variation of the copolymer solubility parameter with the mole fraction of ethylene.

5.   Finishing Up

Select the File/Exit command from the top menu bar and click Exit in the blue dialog box that pops up. Alternatively, if you wish to continue on with other work, select the File/New Session command and click Confirm in the blue dialog box.

Summary

In this short example, you:

You can also build and edit monomers using the building capabilities of the 3D Sketcher, (accessible via the Build/3D-Sketch item on the top menu bar).

For further practice with tutorials in Synthia or other polymer modules, please see the Cerius2 Tutorials--Materials Science book.


General methodology

Calculable properties

Table 1 lists the properties that you can calculate with Synthia, together with references to the expressions in Bicerano (1993) that are evaluated when performing these calculations, and an estimate of the standard deviation in the predicted values. In many cases, the standard deviations are values of standard deviations in the mean that are taken directly from the correlations performed in Bicerano (1993). For some properties, correlations in Bicerano (1993) were performed against values computed from group contributions. In these cases, the values of standard deviation listed in Table 1 are a combination of uncertainties in the correlations performed in Bicerano (1993) and uncertainties in the original group contribution approach (the latter usually being the major contributor). The standard deviations listed in Table 1 are only intended to serve as a guide for you to assess the relative merit of the large range of properties that may be computed by the Synthia module.

Table 1. Properties Calculable By the Synthia Module

Property Reference+ Standard Deviation
Thermophysical Properties  
van der Waals volume   Eq. 3.10, 3.11; p. 54   1.8%  
Glass transition temperature   Eq. 6.2, 6.3; p. 145, 148   6.7%  
Temp. of half decomposition   Eq. 16.3, 16.4; p. 338, 341   7.0%  
Coeff. vol. thermal expansion   Eq. 3.15, 3.16, 3.17; p. 73   6.7%  
Molar volume      
at 298 K   Eq. 3.13, 3.14; p. 65   2.2%  
at other temps.   Eq. 3.15, 3.16, 3.18, 3.19;p.73   2.5%  
Density      
at 298 K   Eq. 3.13, 3.14; p. 65   2.2%  
at other temps.   Eq. 3.15, 3.16, 3.18, 3.19;p.73   2.5%  
Molar heat cap. of solid      
at 298 K   Eq. 4.13; p. 86   5.0%  
at other temps.   Eq. 4.10; p. 81   7.0%  
Molar heat cap. of liquid      
at 298 K   Eq. 4.14; p. 92   4.7%  
at other temps.   Eq. 4.15; p. 92   15%  
Change in molar heat cap at Tg   Eq. 4.17; p. 97   17%  
Cohesive energy at 298 K  
Fedors   Eq. 5.8, 5.9, 5.10; p. 110, 111   3.9%  
van Krevelen   Eq. 5.12, 5.13; p. 115, 116   3.0%  
Solubility parameter at 298 K  
Fedors   Eq. 5.4; p. 106   3.0%  
van Krevelen   Eq. 5.4; p. 106   2.6%  
Surface Tension  
Molar parachor   Eq. 7.2, 7.9, 7.10; p. 164, 168   4.0%  
Fedors at 298 K   Eq. 7.1; p. 163   5.0%  
van Krevelen at 298 K   Eq. 7.1; p. 163   5.0%  
Thermal conductivity  
at 298 K   Eq. 14.6, 14.7; p. 315   10.2%  
at other temps.   Eq. 14.2, 14.3; p. 311   12.7%  
Electrical, Optical, and Magnetic Properties  
Refractive index  
at 298 K   Eq. 8.5, 8.6; p. 179, 180   1.0%  
at other temps.   Eq. 8.1, p. 176   3.0%  
Molar refraction at 298 K   Eq. 8.3; p. 177   2.6%  
Dielectric constant at 298 K   Eq. 9.11, 9.12; p. 202, 203   3.0%  
Volume resistivity at 298 K   Eq. 9.7; p. 200   20%  
Diamagnetic susceptibility at 298 K   Eq. 10.3, 10.4; p. 228   5.0%  
Mechanical Properties  
Bulk modulus   Eq. 11.13; p. 239   15%  
Shear modulus   Eq. 11.7; p. 236   18%  
Young's modulus   Eq. 11.7; p. 236   18%  
Poisson's ratio  
at 298 K   Eq. 11.10; p. 239   3%  
at other temps.   Eq. 11.12; p. 239   5%  
Shear yield stress   Eq. 11.23; p. 251   20%  
Brittle fracture stress   Eq. 11.22; p. 250   20%  
Chain Stiffness and Entanglement Properties  
Steric hindrance parameter   Eq. 12.13; p. 281   4.5%  
Characteristic ratio   Eq. 12.14, 12.15; p. 285   9.0%  
Molar stiffness function   Eq. 12.19; p. 288   10%  
Entanglement molecular weight   Eq. 11.18; p. 243   30%  
Critical molecular weight   Eq. 11.17; p. 243   30%  
Entanglement length     30%  
Transport Properties  
Activation energy for viscous flow   Eq. 13.8, 13.15; p. 298, 302   3%  
Permeability of oxygen   Eq. 15.13; p. 325   50%  
Permeability of nitrogen   Eq. 15.14; p. 325   50%  
Permeability of carbon dioxide   Eq. 15.15; p. 325   50%  
Zero-Shear Viscosity   Eq. 13.9,13.10;p. 298,299    

+Bicerano (1993).

Scope and limitations

The correlations implemented in the Synthia module were developed for isotropic (unoriented) amorphous atactic homopolymers and alternating and random copolymers constructed from the following nine elements: carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, silicon, sulfur, fluorine, chlorine, and bromine. They are also applicable to the amorphous phase of semi-crystalline polymers. Consequently, the following predictions are beyond the scope of Synthia: effects of tacticity, ordering (crystallinity and liquid crystallinity), and orientation of polymers; predictions for cross-linked, ladder, and biological polymers, for block copolymers, and for polymeric systems containing additives and impurities that have a significant effect on the properties of the polymer. Also, Synthia does not predict the dependence of most properties on molecular weight; the estimates correspond to typical high molecular weight polymers (the only current exception is zero-shear viscosity as defined in chapter 13 of Bicerano (1993).

Computing repeat unit length

The repeat unit length is used in correlations for many of the mechanical properties. To compute this distance appropriately, you should set all repeat units to their fully extended all-trans conformations and energy minimize these structures before you submit them to Synthia. For most polymer repeat units, you can adequately perform this minimization using the Run item on the MINIMIZER card in the OFF Methods deck.

All repeat units you submit to Synthia are assumed to be in the all-trans conformation. If you use monomers from the monomer library, the head and tail atom of the unit are predefined; if you are building your own monomers, you must select the head and tail atom before doing a Synthia calculation using the Edit Monomer item on the POLYMER BUILDER card. Typically you have several choices of head and tail atom for the monomer that are topologically equivalent to the selected one; the program identifies the pair {T, T'} that is most widely separated.

The bond lengths that connect T and T' to terminal heavy backbone atoms H and H' are next extrapolated to the expected bond length between monomeric units, that is, between the atom types corresponding to H and H'. The distances between these extrapolated positions of the terminal atoms and the corresponding terminal heavy atoms at the opposite end of the unit are measured. The repeat unit length is then computed as:

Eq. 1            

Energy minimization of repeat units

It is advised that you energy minimize all repeat units before submitting them to the Synthia module. The fact that minimization may affect the repeat unit length determined by Synthia has been mentioned in the previous section. In turn, this length affects several other aspects of geometry used to compute polymer properties. To achieve adequate minimization of structures it is usually sufficient to follow these steps:

1.   Set repeat units to their all-trans conformation.

2.   Set all parameters to their default values.

3.   Select the Run item from the MINIMIZER card in the OFF METHODS deck.

Values of cohesive energy and solubility parameter used in correlations for other properties

Two independent values are computed for the cohesive energy of a polymer, and subsequently two corresponding values are calculated for the solubility parameter. These two sets of values result from correlations to cohesive energies predicted by group contributions developed by Fedors (1974a and b) and van Krevelen (1990). Consequently, they are termed Fedors-like and van Krevelen-like values, and are listed this way in the output file.

Values of cohesive energy and solubility parameters are used in correlations to predict other properties. Unless explicitly stated otherwise in the output file, any value of cohesive energy that is so used is the Fedors-like quantity, but any value of solubility parameter is the van Krevelen-like quantity.

Representation of amide groups

It is recommended that you build amide and similar functional groups with the following structure:

That is, try to use only single and double bonds and no partial double bonds. Synthia uses bond type information to compute several properties, and this type of construction is necessary to maintain consistency with the way in which Synthia was parameterized.

Units of permeability

The units for the permeability values that are given in the Synthia output file are: cm3 mil (day 100 inches2 atm)-1, which are often referred to as "Dow Units" (DU). Here, mil denotes one thousandth of an inch.

Developing correlations with QSAR

The Synthia module allows you to develop your own correlations for properties if you also have access to the QSAR module, with which Synthia is integrated. The Correlate item on the SYNTHIA card automatically brings up a QSAR table. In addition to the structural descriptors used internally by Synthia, all the properties available for prediction in Synthia at 298 K and for a molecular weight of 100000 are available for use as descriptors in QSAR studies.

For a detailed description of the significance of various structural parameters useful in correlating polymer properties, please see Bicerano (1993).

Performing polymer properties calculations

The method for performing polymer properties calculations involves the following steps:

1.   Build or edit monomers by selecting the Build/3D-Sketch item from the top menu bar of the Visualizer panel. Alternatively, you can select monomers from the monomer library: these are accessible directly within Synthia during homopolymer and copolymer calculations.

2.   If you build your own monomers, go to the POLYMER BUILDER card and select the Edit Monomers item to bring up the Monomer Editor control panel. Use the icons on this panel to define the head and tail atom of the monomer.

Note

Step 2 is not necessary for structures in the monomer library, since they have predefined head and tail atoms.  

3.   To perform a homopolymer study, go to the SYNTHIA card and select the Study/Homopolymer item. Click the arrow next to the Monomer label on the Homopolymer panel and select the monomer you are interested in from the displayed monomer list.

To use a model you have built, select Models from the monomer list and pick your monomer. Type a name for your homopolymer in the box labeled Polymer and enter a temperature for the study.

4.   Add the homopolymer to the study by pushing the Add Homopolymer to Study button.

5.   For a copolymer study, select the Study/Copolymer item to display the Copolymer control panel. Choose up to five constituent monomers from the monomer choosers under Monomer Name.

To access a monomer you have built, select Models from the list and then the pick the specific monomer of interest. To assign a fixed concentration to a monomer, check the Fixed box associated with it and enter the concentration in the text field to its right. Note that concentrations are in either mole or weight fractions; unassigned fractions are automatically divided equally among unfixed monomers to bring the total to one.

When the copolymer is fully defined, click the Add button to add it to either a new or current study.

6.   To choose which properties to predict for your polymer, go to the SYNTHIA card and select the Properties/Select item to open the Select Properties panel. Choose the category of properties you are interested in from the yellow popup above the property list. Then click on properties within the list displayed to add them to the set of properties to compute in your study.

Note that you can make multiple selections by dragging the mouse or by combining mouse clicks with the control and shift keys.

7.   Display the study table by selecting the Study/Show item.

8.   To display the selected properties for the homopolymer or copolymer of interest, click the PREDICT button on the Study Table.

9.   For homopolymers you can go directly to the Predict panel by selecting the Predict Properties item on the SYNTHIA card. Pick a monomer and select properties for prediction.

You can display and select different property categories using the category chooser located above the list of shown properties. You can perform calculations on models chosen from the Models window on the Visualizer panel. To do this:

a.   Check the Selected Models box on the Predict panel

b.   Click the Predict Properties button to display the results of the calculation in the current table.

10.   To calculate properties over a temperature range, go to the top menu bar in the Study Table and select the Ranges/Temperature Range item (or you can select the Study/Temperature Range item from the SYNTHIA card). This opens the Temperature control panel.

a.   Select the homopolymer or copolymer to use as the subject of the study from the list you see when you click the
Polymer arrow button.

b.   Enter a Start Temperature.

c.   Enter a Final Temperature.

d.   Enter a Temperature Step.

e.   Check the Display Range in Table box to display the results of the temperature range calculation in the Study table. (Or you can click the Plot button to display the predictions of selected properties graphically.)

11.   To calculate the properties of a copolymer over a concentration range, go to the top menu bar in the Study Table and select the Ranges/Concentration Range item (or select the Study/
Concentration Range
item on the SYNTHIA card). This brings up the Concentration Range panel.

a.   Select a copolymer for the study from the Polymer list

b.   Select a monomer as the Range variable from the list of allowed range monomers displayed by clicking the yellow popup.

c.   Pick initial and final concentrations and a concentration step for the range monomer.

d.   As in the case of temperature ranges, either use the Display Range in Table check box to display the results of the calculation in the Study table or click the Plot button to view the results graphically.

12.   To develop your own correlations (if you have access to the QSAR module), select the Correlate/QSAR Study Table item from the SYNTHIA card. This brings up a QSAR Study Table. Using the items on the Molecules pulldown in the QSAR Study Table's menu bar, add any molecules of interest; use the Descriptors/ Databases item to identify the descriptors to employ in the QSAR study.

Double-clicking on a column of descriptors already added to the QSAR Study Table brings up help information on the name and significance of the descriptor.


Theory

Background

Group additive methods have been used successfully for many years to predict the properties of polymers as well as small molecules. These methods are extremely fast and easy to use. Consequently, they are of greatest utility when a rapid estimate of a property is required without a detailed understanding of the atomistic interactions that give rise to it. However, the principal shortcoming of these methods is their reliance upon a database of group contributions, the contents of which are obtained by fitting to experimentally observed properties of interest. Thus, if a polymer contains a group for which the group contribution cannot be estimated, then the property of that polymer cannot be calculated.

To circumvent this limitation, the method implemented in the
Synthia module uses topological information about polymers (instead of group contributions) in the predictive correlations. Specifically, connectivity indices derived from graph theory are employed. Thus, no database of group contributions is required, and properties may be predicted for any polymer comprised of any of the nine elements: carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, oxygen, silicon, sulfur, fluorine, chlorine, and bromine.

No attempt is made here to discuss or explain the details of all of the correlations that are used within the Synthia module. For this information, refer to Jozef Bicerano's research monograph (Bicerano 1993). The description of the theory underlying this module is restricted in this document to a brief outline summarized from Bicerano's work. A complete description is given, however, of all assumptions and modifications made to the original approach (Bicerano 1993) in the course of implementing this computer program.

Connectivity indices of polymer repeat units

In this section a brief description is given of how connectivity indices are determined for polymer repeat units. For more detailed information see Bicerano (1993), and Kier and Hall (1976, 1986).

Graphical theoretical treatment of molecular properties starts by construction of the hydrogen-suppressed graph of the molecule. To represent a repeat unit, special considerations are required to take into account chain continuation in a consistent manner, and not introduce truncation errors. The procedure is illustrated here by considering the repeat unit of poly(vinyl fluoride) (PVF). This repeat unit is shown in Figure 2, together with the hydrogen-suppressed graph that will be utilized.

Figure 2 . The Repeat Unit (a), and
Corresponding Hydrogen-Suppressed Graph (b)

The next step is to define two atomic indices ( and ), that describe the bonding and electronic environment of each non-hydrogen atom. The first is the simple connectivity index, , which equals the number of non-hydrogen atoms to which an atom is bonded. The latter atomic index, , contains electronic configuration information for the atom and is given by:

Eq. 2            

where is the number of valence electrons of the atom, is the number of hydrogens bonded to it, and is its atomic number.

Bond indices and can also be defined in terms of the atomic indices. These are defined by:

Eq. 3            

and:

Eq. 4            

The values of the atomic and bond indices that are obtained for the PVF repeat unit are shown in Figure 3. In this figure the connectivity indices and are shown in Figure 3(a), and the valence indices and are shown in Figure 3(b).

Figure 3 . The Atomic and Bond Connectivity (a), and Valence (b) Indices for the PVF Repeat Unit

Connectivity indices of polymer chains

The connectivity indices for the polymer chain can now be defined. It is these chain connectivity indices that are later used in the correlations with polymer properties.

The zeroth-order (atomic) connectivity indices and for the polymer molecule are defined in terms of the summations:

Eq. 5            

and:

Eq. 6            

over the vertices of the hydrogen-suppressed graph.

The first-order (bond) connectivity indices and for the polymer molecule are defined in terms of the summations:

Eq. 7            

and:

Eq. 8            

over the edges of the hydrogen-suppressed graph.

Thus, for PVF we have:

Eq. 9            

Eq. 10            

Eq. 11            

Eq. 12            

Note that the and values outside of the square brackets in Figure 3 are not included in the summations. They are included in the figure to take the chain connectivity into account, and to allow the correct assignment of the and values for all of the atoms and bonds within the brackets.

General forms of the correlations in terms of connectivity indices

Extensive properties depend upon the size of the system, and their values increase in direct proportion to the amount of material present. Examples of such properties include: molar volume, molar heat capacity, and cohesive energy. Such properties are correlated directly with the values of .

Intensive properties are essentially independent of the amount of material present, providing that it is nonzero. These properties are correlated with values of scaled by the number of non-hydrogen atoms in the system N. These scaled values are denoted by the Greek letter , with all the usual superscripts and subscripts that are used with the corresponding .

Thus, two general forms of correlation are used:

Eq. 13            

Eq. 14            

Here, a and b are sets of linear regression coefficients. There is no additive constant term in the correlation for an extensive property because the value of constant does not change as a function of the amount of material present. The structural parameters are combinations of connectivity indices and geometrical parameters that are used in correlations for certain properties. The atomic and group correction terms are terms that are dependent upon the number of certain types of atoms or groups that may be present.

Backbone and side group connectivity indices

In correlations to predict certain properties, it is necessary to separate the contributions of atoms in the backbone and those in side chains into two sets of s. This is not discussed further here--for additional information please see Bicerano (1993).

Actual correlations for various properties and validation against experimental data

All the correlations used in the Synthia module are fully documented in Bicerano (1993), in addition to their validation against extensive experimental data.


References

Bicerano, J. Prediction of Polymer Properties, Marcel Dekker, Inc.: New York (1993).

Elias, H.G.; Vohwinkel, F. New Commercial Polymers 2, Gordon and Breach Science Publishers: New York (1986).

Fedors, R.F. Polymer Engineering and Science, 14, 147-154 (1974a).

Fedors, R.F. Polymer Engineering and Science, 14, 472 (1974b)

Kier, L.B.; Hall, L.H. Molecular Connectivity in Chemistry and Drug Research, Academic Press: New York (1976).

Kier, L.B.; Hall, L.H. Molecular Connectivity in Structure-Activity Analysis, John Wiley & Sons: New York (1986).

van Krevelen, D.W.; Hoftyzer, P.J. Properties of Polymers, Their Estimation and Correlation with Chemical Structure, 2nd Edition, Elsevier: New York (1990).




Last updated December 08, 1998 at 07:23PM Pacific Standard Time.
Copyright © 1998, Molecular Simulations, Inc. All rights reserved.