Chemical Regulation of Gene Expressions
J.M. Gottesfeld, R.. Burnett, D. Herman, K. Jenssen, S. Ku., E.
Soragni, D. Alvarez*, P.B. Dervan**
Small Molecule Regulation of Gene Expression
The ability to control gene expression at will has been a longstanding
goal in molecular biology and human medicine. Studies in our laboratory
are focused pyrrole--imidazole polyamides, a class of small molecules
that can be programmed by chemical synthesis to recognize a wide range
of DNA sequences. Below we summarize recent efforts toward the development
of polyamides as therapeutics for human disease, and the identification
of another class of small molecules that offer promise in the treatment
of neurodegenerative diseases.
Identification of Histone Deacetylase Inhibitors that Reverse
Frataxin Gene Silencing
We examined the chromatin structure of the frataxin gene in normal
and FRDA cell lines using antibodies to the various modification states
of the core histones and chromatin immunoprecipitation methods. We
find that gene silencing at expanded frataxin alleles is accompanied
by hypoacetylation of histones H3 and H4, and methylation of histone
H3 at lysine 9, consistent with a heterochromatin-mediated repression
mechanism. These findings suggest that histone deacetylase (HDAC)
inhibitors, compounds that reverse heterochromatin, might activate
the frataxin gene. We identified one commercial HDAC inhibitor, BML--210,
that partially reverses silencing in the FRDA cell line. Based on
the structure of this compound, we synthesized and assayed a series
of derivatives of BML-210 and identified HDAC inhibitors that reverse
frataxin silencing in primary lymphocytes from Friedreich’s
patients. These molecules act directly on the histones associated
with the frataxin gene, increasing acetylation at particular lysine
residues on histones H3 and H4 (H3-K14, H4-K5 and H4-K12). Unlike
many triplet-repeat diseases (for example, the polyglutamine expansion
diseases such as Huntington’s disease and the spinocerebellar
ataxias), expanded GAA·TTC triplets do not alter the coding
potential of the frataxin gene; thus, gene activation would be of
therapeutic benefit. Animal studies are currently underway to explore
the bioavailability and efficacy of these molecules.
Please visit the Friedreich's Ataxia Research Alliance
website for more information on Friedreich's Ataxia news and research
www.faresearchalliance.org
Blocking Cancer Cell Proliferation with a Polyamide-Chlorambucil Conjugate
One common DNA alkylator in clinical use for a variety of lymphatic
cancers is the nitrogen mustard chlorambucil. Since chlorambucil alkylates
DNA at all potentially available guanine residues in the genome, coupling
of chlorambucil to a polyamide will increase the DNA sequence specificity
and perhaps decrease unwanted side effects, while retaining the ability
of the compound to kill cancer cells. We recently reported that a
specific polyamide-chlorambucil conjugate called 1R--Chl alters the
morphology and growth characteristics of colon carcinoma cells in
culture, and causes these cells to arrest in the G2/M stage of the
cell cycle, without any apparent cytotoxicity. Cells treated with
this compound fail to grow in soft agar, and do not form tumors in
nude mice, indicating that polyamide--treated cells are no longer
tumorigenic. The compound blocks proliferation of metastatic colon
carcinoma cells in immunocompromised mice, and no apparent toxicity
is observed at doses required for a therapeutic effect. Importantly,
this gene-targeted small molecule requires no delivery vehicle as
the molecule is cell permeable and localizes in the nucleus of various
cancer cell lines. The gene target of 1R--Chl was identified as histone
H4c by microarray analysis, a member of the gene family that encodes
a critical component of cellular chromatin, and a gene that is highly
expressed in a wide range of cancer cells. Reduction in histone H4
protein by polyamide treatment was confirmed in cells treated with
this agent, causing chromatin decondensation.
To confirm that down regulation of histone H4c transcription is the
primary event leading to cell cycle arrest by 1R--Chl, we turned to
siRNAs directed toward H4c mRNA. Unlike 1R--Chl, which arrests cells
at the G2/M phase of the cell cycle, the same cells treated with the
H4c siRNA are arrested at the G1/S phase. However, G2/M arrest by
1R--Chl and down regulation of the H4c gene can be confirmed in other
tumorigenic cell lines. We find that 1R--Chl causes extensive DNA
damage in colon cancer cells, leading to phosphorylation of histone
H2A.X at Ser 139 and recruitment of the DNA repair protein Nbs1 to
discrete sites in the genome. These events are hallmarks of the cellular
DNA damage response pathway. Control polyamide-Chl conjugates that
lack binding sites in the H4c gene, and have no anti--proliferative
effects by themselves, are able to cause G2/M cell-cycle arrest when
cells are treated with these polyamide conjugates and siRNAs to histone
mRNAs.
Based on these findings, we propose that 1R--Chl exerts its anti-proliferative
effect through a novel two--hit mechanism. The highly transcribed
H4c gene in several cancer cell lines is a primary target for DNA
alkylation by 1R--Chl, resulting in down-regulation of H4c transcription
and histone H4 protein. Loss of histone protein leads to a transition
from condensed to open chromatin, exposing otherwise hidden 1R--Chl
binding sites. These sites are then alkylated by 1R--Chl, causing
widespread DNA damage and a cascade of events leading to G2/M arrest
and loss of tumorigenecity. Our findings demonstrate how a single
molecule can target cancer cells due to a specific gene expression
profile, and block cancer cell proliferation. Ongoing studies are
aimed at the development of 1R--Chl as a potential human cancer therapeutic.
Polyamides as Activators of Gene Expression
The neurodegenerative disease Friedreich’s ataxia (FRDA) is
caused by gene silencing through expansion of GAA•TTC triplet
repeats in the first intron of a nuclear gene that encodes the essential
mitochondrial protein frataxin. Normal frataxin alleles have 6 --
34 repeats while FRDA patient alleles have 66 -- 1700 repeats. Longer
repeats cause a more profound frataxin deficiency and are associated
with earlier onset and increased severity of the disease. Two models
have been proposed to account for gene silencing by expanded GAA•TTC
repeats, unusual DNA structures and repressive heterochromatin.
Molecules that reverse unusual DNA structures and/or heterochromatin
formation in the frataxin gene would likely increase transcription
through expanded GAA•TTC repeats, thereby relieving the deficiency
in frataxin mRNA and protein in FRDA cells. We find that polyamides
targeting GAA•TTC repeats partially alleviate transcription
repression of the frataxin gene in a cell line derived from white
blood cells from a FRDA patient. These molecules also increase frataxin
protein levels in these cells, and microarray studies show that a
limited number of genes in the human genome are affected by polyamides
targeting GAA•TTC repeat DNA. We hypothesize that polyamides
might act as a thermodynamic “sink” and lock GAA•TTC
repeats into double stranded B DNA. Such an event would disfavor duplex
unpairing, which is necessary for formation of the unusual DNA structures
associated with expanded triplet repeats. Alternatively, polyamides
may relieve heterochromatin-mediated repression by opening the chromatin
domain containing the frataxin gene. To explore this latter hypothesis,
we turned to another class of small molecules.