Kinetic Methodology
Prof. Blackmond has pioneered the
development of Reaction Progress Kinetic Analysis (RPKA), a methodology
combining highly accurate in-situ data collection with a rigorous mathematical
analysis that permits rapid determination of concentration dependences of
reactants. In contrast to the classical role of kinetics, in which measurements
of concentration dependences most often are asked simply to corroborate a
previously proposed mechanism, the Blackmond group’s approach is to employ
kinetic studies at the outset of an investigation of ill-defined reaction
network to suggest reaction mechanisms. This “kinetic-assisted mechanistic
analysis” aids in the design of further supporting experiments including
conventional mechanistic tools such as studies of isotope effects and
spectroscopic studies for structural and compositional information. One of the
most powerful aspects of the methodology is its ability to deconvolute rate
processes occurring on the catalytic cycle from those occurring off the cycle.
Prominent examples of the application of this methodology to quantitative
understanding of complex organic reactions and reaction networks include
asymmetric hydrogenation, asymmetric organocatalytic reactions, Pd-catalyzed
C-C and C-N bond forming reactions, and transition-metal catalyzed competitive
reactions including kinetic resolutions. Reaction Progress Kinetic Analysis
finds important application in the pharmaceutical industry, where streamlining
process R&D based on Blackmond’s kinetic analysis is becoming an
industry-wide standard.
Nonlinear effects of
catalyst enantiopurity
Experimental and
theoretical studies in the Blackmond group have derived relationships between
catalyst ee and reaction rate that complement the standard tool of studying
product ee as a function of catalyst ee. Prof. Blackmond’s work provides a
means of testing proposed models for nonlinear effects and expands the power of
studies of nonlinear effects to serve as a meaningful mechanistic probe. The
concepts developed in this work led Prof. Blackmond to consideration of what
has been termed the “ultimate nonlinear effect”, that of the origin of
biological homochirality. She carried out the first kinetic studies and
developed the first kinetic model exploring the mechanism of asymmetric
amplification in the Soai autocatalytic reaction. She continues investigations
of this reaction, with current projects focusing on determining the nature of
the transition state species in this reaction as well as probing spatiotemporal
aspects of absolute asymmetric synthesis by carrying out autocatalysis in
well-defined microfluidic reactor networks.
Biological homochirality
and amino acid phase behavior
More recently Prof.
Blackmond has expanded the range of models to rationalize the origin of
biological homochirality from proposals based purely on chemical reactions to
those based on physical phase behavior of chiral molecules as well as a
combination of chemical and physical processes. She has demonstrated that
highly enantioenriched solutions of amino acids can be produced from nearly
racemic mixtures via solution-solid partitioning of the enantiomers. Reactions
catalyzed by amino acids that are carried out in such systems show nonlinear
product ee consistent with this highly enantioenriched solution composition.
This concept was then greatly expanded in scope with the discovery that eutetic
compositions could be “tuned” by judicious choice of additives that alter
crystal structure and solubility. In sharp contrast to autocatalytic reaction
models, which invoke “far-from-equilibrium” behavior, this eutectic model is a
pure equilibrium treatment. This distinction has important implications for
scenarios concerning the time course over which the evolution of homochirality
may have developed. Probing the phase behavior of amino acids in conjunction
with solution racemization led to separate work showing how one hand of a
chiral solid could be transformed completely into its enantiomorph from a
nearly racemic mixture of the two. Because interconversion in solution allows
an enantiomer that had been part of an L crystal to become part of a D crystal,
this has been dubbed the “chiral amnesia” process.